Table of Contents
Home > Blog > Disability Insurance > The Difference Between Group and Individual Physician Disability Insurance

The Difference Between Group and Individual Physician Disability Insurance

jon tyson PXB7yEM5LVs unsplash

As a physician, your ability to work is directly tied to your income. What happens if you’re unable to practice due to illness or injury? That’s where disability insurance comes into play. As your go-to insurance expert for physicians, LeverageRx is here to help you navigate through the options. In this post, we will discuss the differences between Group and Individual Physician Disability Insurance.

What is Group Physician Disability Insurance?

Group Physician Disability Insurance is a policy that covers a group of physicians, usually through a medical practice or a professional association. The coverage is typically less expensive per person and is often paid for by the employer or association. These group policies are designed to provide income protection for physicians if they become unable to work due to illness or injury. Because the risk is spread among a larger group of individuals, premiums tend to be lower, making this an attractive option for healthcare institutions aiming to offer competitive employee benefits.

However, the coverage in group policies is not as extensive, and benefits may be capped at a certain level, which won’t match a physician’s current salary. Additionally, the policy is tied to the group, meaning that if a physician leaves the practice or association, they will lose this coverage.

Pros of Group Physician Disability Insurance:

Lower Cost: Group rates are generally lower than individual rates. This is because the risk is spread across multiple members of the group, allowing insurance companies to offer lower premiums per person. You can check your individual rates here.
Ease of Enrollment: Generally, there is minimal underwriting involved in group disability insurance, making the enrollment process fast. In many cases, medical examinations aren’t required, which can be beneficial for physicians with pre-existing conditions.
Employer Sponsored: Often, a significant portion of the premium for group disability insurance is paid for by the employer or association. This can relieve the financial burden on the physician and make the benefit affordable.

Cons of Group Physician Disability Insurance:

Less Customization: Group plans have fewer options for customization. Physicians often find that the terms of the group policy, including the benefit period and coverage amount, are not suitable for their specific needs and financial situation.
Not Portable: When a physician leaves the group or employer, they lose their group disability insurance coverage. Some group policies offer a conversion option, but this can lead to higher premiums and involve underwriting.
Offers Less Coverage: The benefit amount in group policies is capped at a lower level compared to individual policies. This means that in the event of a disability, the benefits received would not be sufficient to maintain the physician’s current lifestyle and financial obligations.
Generic Definitions of Disability: Group policies often have poor definitions of disability, which makes it harder for a physician to qualify for benefits. For example, these policies typically require the physician to be unable to work in any occupation, not just their medical specialty, to receive benefits.
doctor putting a cast on patient's wrist

What is Individual Physician Disability Insurance?

Individual Physician Disability Insurance is a policy that a physician purchases independently to provide income protection. This policy is tailored specifically to the individual, allowing for customization in terms of benefit amounts, waiting periods, and specific riders that can be added for enhanced protection. Since this insurance is not tied to an employer or group, it remains with the physician regardless of job changes, providing consistent and long-term security. Although premiums for individual policies may be higher, they offer a level of stability and specificity that group policies might not provide. In essence, Individual Physician Disability Insurance acts as a safeguard, ensuring that physicians can maintain their standard of living if they are unable to practice due to illness or injury.

Pros of Individual Physician Disability Insurance:

Customization: Individual policies are tailored to suit specific needs and circumstances. This means that physicians choose the benefit period, elimination period, and specific riders that align with their lifestyle and financial goals. This level of customization allows physicians to have a policy that is uniquely suited to their situation.
Portability: One of the most significant advantages of individual disability insurance is that the policy stays with the physician, regardless of job changes. This is crucial for doctors who may switch employers, go into private practice, or move across states, as their coverage remains uninterrupted.
Higher Coverage Levels: With individual policies, physicians are able to secure a higher benefit amount based on their income and needs. This ensures that they are adequately covered and can maintain their current standard of living in case of a disability.
Own-Occupation Definition of Disability: Individual policies offer “own-occupation” coverage, which means the policy will pay benefits if the physician is unable to work in their specific medical specialty, even if they could work in another field. This is the most important thing to look for in a disability insurance policy. To get a true own-occupation disability policy, start here.

Cons of Individual Physician Disability Insurance:

Higher Cost: Individual policies generally have higher premiums than group policies. While they offer more extensive and tailored coverage, which can be a significant financial commitment, especially for young physicians or those with tight budgets. Fortunately, the companies that offer true own occupation policies also offer huge discounts to physicians in training.
Medical Underwriting: Applying for an individual policy often involves a more thorough review of the applicant’s health status. This can include a medical exam and a detailed health questionnaire, which might be challenging for those with pre-existing conditions.
More Complex Application Process: Since individual policies are more customized, the application process can be more extensive and time-consuming. Physicians will likely need to provide more documentation and work closely with an insurance advisor.

young african american doctor working on a laptop (searching moonlighting opportunities for residents) Key Differences Between Group and Individual Physician Disability Insurance:

Cost: Group policies generally have lower premiums, as the risk is spread across multiple members, and employers often subsidize the cost. Individual policies typically have higher premiums, reflecting the personalized nature of the coverage and the specific risk assessment of the individual physician. Those who get an individual policy while in medical school, residency, or fellowship will benefit from the large training discounts available.

Portability: Individual policies are portable and remain with physicians throughout their career changes, which means they provide continuous protection. Group policies, are often tied to a specific employer or association, which may result in a loss of coverage if the physician changes jobs or leaves the group.

Customization: Individual policies allow for extensive customization, enabling physicians to select benefit amounts, waiting periods, and riders that best fit their unique circumstances and financial goals. Group policies have standardized terms and offer fewer options for customization.

Coverage Amount: Individual policies often enable higher coverage amounts that can be tailored to a physician’s specific income and lifestyle needs. Group policies have caps on benefits, which might not align with the physician’s salary or financial obligations.

Definition of Disability: Individual policies often offer more favorable definitions of disability, including “own-occupation” definitions that pay if a physician can’t work in their specific medical specialty. Group policies may have more restrictive definitions, requiring the physician to be unable to work in any occupation to receive benefits.

Policy Ownership: With individual disability insurance, the physician owns the policy, which provides control and stability. With group policies, the employer or association holds the policy, and physicians lose their coverage if their employment situation changes.

Premium Stability: Individual policies have the option to include guaranteed renewable and non-cancelable terms, meaning premiums won’t change and coverage cannot be canceled as long as premiums are paid. Group policy premiums are subject to change based on the overall claims experience of the group.

Underwriting Process: Individual policies usually involve a more rigorous medical underwriting process, which can deter those with health issues. Group policies typically have simplified or guaranteed issue underwriting, making it easier for physicians to obtain coverage.

How to Choose the Right Policy for You

The choice between group and individual physician disability insurance should be based on your unique circumstances and career goals.

Assess Your Financial Needs and Goals: Start by evaluating your current financial situation and future goals. Calculate how much income you would need to maintain your lifestyle if you were unable to work due to a disability. Consider your expenses, debts, and any dependents relying on your income.

Understand the Policy Terms: Make sure you understand key terms such as the benefit period, elimination period, and definitions of disability. The “own-occupation” definition of a disability is the most important thing to look for – it ensures that the policy pays benefits if you can’t work in your specific medical specialty.

Compare Costs and Benefits: Weigh the cost of the premiums against the benefits you would receive. While group policies might be more affordable, individual policies often offer more comprehensive and tailored coverage.

Check Policy Portability: If you anticipate changing jobs or moving, consider the value of a portable individual policy that will stay with you regardless of your employer.

Consult with a Professional: Speak with a financial advisor or insurance expert who understands the unique needs of physicians. They can help you navigate the complexities of disability insurance and recommend a policy that aligns with your personal and professional circumstances.

Check Your Rates with a Broker: LeverageRx is a powerful resource for physicians seeking disability insurance. We’ll help you compare rates and options from various insurers in one place. By using LeverageRx, you can efficiently evaluate different policies and make an informed decision based on your specific needs and budget.

Review and Update Regularly: Your insurance needs can change as your life and career evolve. Regularly reviewing and, if necessary, updating your policy ensures that your coverage continues to align with your current situation.

Consider Additional Riders: Think about adding riders (additional policy features) such as a cost-of-living adjustment and the future purchase option, which allows you to increase coverage as your income grows, without additional medical underwriting.

Key Takeaways

The decision between Group and Individual Physician Disability Insurance is pivotal and depends on various personal and professional factors. Group policies often provide a cost-effective, convenient solution through employer-sponsored programs, while individual policies offer tailored, portable, and potentially more comprehensive coverage. As a physician, safeguarding your ability to earn an income is essential, so making an informed decision is crucial. By consulting with a professionals like LeverageRx, you can secure the peace of mind that comes with knowing you are protected, regardless of what the future may hold.