Medical Malpractice Payouts by State

Read Time

5 mins

IN THIS ARTICLE
IN THIS ARTICLE

Which states have the highest medical malpractice payouts? Which states offer the lowest medical payouts? As a student, resident, fellow or practicing doctor, dentist, surgeon, veterinarian, chiropractor, nurse practitioner or dermatologist, you may want to know about medical malpractice settlements where you intend to work. A study by Johns Hopkins University, more than 250,000 people in the U.S. die every year from medical errors and negligence. This makes medical malpractice the third-leading cause of death in the United States.

More than one in three physicians have had a medical liability lawsuit filed against them at some point in their careers, says the American Medical Association’s Division of Economic and Health Policy Research. The longer in practice, the more likely they’ll experience a suit. Nearly half of physicians 55 and older report having been sued, compared with just 8% of doctors younger than 40. Female physicians are also less likely to face a lawsuit compared to male physicians, and differences in age and specialty do come into play.

We’ll take a look at medical malpractice payouts by state (including medical malpractice payouts by state 2020). We’ll also name the state with the largest malpractice settlement, states that cap malpractice lawsuits, and how to get medical malpractice insurance with LeverageRx.

What is Medical Malpractice?

Medical malpractice is a violation of a recognized standard of care for the profession that would be exercised by any reasonable healthcare professional under the same circumstances. Malpractice is also negligence on the part of the provider of the cause of the injury. In the absence of the provider’s influence, the injury would not have occurred.

It’s also medical malpractice when significant damage takes place as a result of an injury inflicted by the negligence of the provider. These damages could include loss of income, pain, and suffering above and beyond the norm such as hardships, large long-term medical bills, to name a few. The most common malpractice claims are misdiagnosis, childbirth injuries, medication errors, anesthesia errors and surgery errors. Medical malpractice insurance, known as professional liability insurance, protects doctors and other medical professionals from liability that results in injury or death of patients.

Medical Malpractice Payouts by State

From 1990 to 2020, states have paid out a total of $151,674,570,000, which breaks down as follows among the following 50 states and Washington, D.C.:

  • Alabama: $1,080,200,000
  • Alaska: $301,380,000
  • Arizona: $2,670,380,000
  • Arkansas: $718,100,000
  • California: $9,716,120,000
  • Colorado: $1,566,480,000
  • Connecticut: $2,800,080,000
  • Delaware: $444,690,000
  • Washington, D.C.: $808,640,000
  • Florida: $10,599,180,000
  • Georgia: $3,883,460,000
  • Hawaii: $487,980,000
  • Idaho: $360,290,000
  • Illinois: $9,510,390,000
  • Indiana: $2,279,840,000
  • Iowa: $1,000,620,000
  • Kansas: $1,141,470,000
  • Kentucky: $1,481,240,000
  • Louisiana: $2,081,620,000
  • Maine: $564,900,000
  • Maryland: $3,212,020,000
  • Massachusetts: $5,089,660,000
  • Michigan: $3,311,300,000
  • Minnesota: $1,236,090,000
  • Mississippi: $953,950,000
  • Missouri: $2,656,690,000
  • Montana: $493,220,000
  • Nebraska: $506,760,000
  • Nevada: $987,800,000
  • New Hampshire: $746,350,000
  • New Jersey: $8,573,310,000
  • New Mexico: $968,100,000
  • New York: $25,679,890,000
  • North Carolina: $2,386,400,000
  • North Dakota: $183,510,000
  • Ohio: $5,256,180,000
  • Oklahoma: $1,444,660,000
  • Oregon: $1,269,860,000
  • Pennsylvania: $13,401,460,000
  • Rhode Island: $608,730,000
  • South Carolina: $1,225,830,000
  • South Dakota: $285,430,000
  • Tennessee: $1,806,980,000
  • Texas: $7,083,470,000
  • Utah: $818,520,000
  • Vermont: $203,380,000
  • Virginia: $2,262,730,000
  • Washington: $2,444,980,000
  • West Virginia: $1,225,560,000
  • Wisconsin: $1,454,420,000
  • Wyoming: $200,260,000

The State with the Largest Ever Settlement? Maryland…

The largest single malpractice verdict in U.S. history occurred in Maryland in 2019. A jury awarded Erica Byrom a $229 million malpractice verdict after her daughter suffered a brain injury at birth at the Johns Hopkins Bayview Medical Center in 2014. A Baltimore judge upheld a $205 million verdict due to a state cap. Doctors at the hospital had given Byrom inaccurate information about her unborn baby in 2014 and told her that she could terminate the pregnancy and gave her the indication that the baby was non-viable. She declined a cesarean section and medical staff stopped monitoring the fetus, which resulted in the baby not getting enough oxygen to her brain. The child now has cerebral palsy and is mentally and physically disabled and will require life-long dependent and medical care. New York has the highest medical malpractice payout from 1990 to 2020 at $25.6 billion. Wyoming had the lowest during that time period, at $200,260,000.

Some States Cap Malpractice Lawsuits

Damages caps limit the amount of non-economic damages that a plaintiff can collect. Each state has its own damages cap but the federal government has put a $250,000 cap on non-economic damages for medical malpractice claims. Twenty-nine states currently have tort reform that places a cap on malpractice damages that have so far survived constitutional challenges. Which states cap malpractice lawsuits? Some states have malpractice limits on pain and suffering while others have a hard cap that cannot be exceeded, no matter what patients suffered. The following states have a cap:

  • Arkansas
  • California
  • Colorado
  • Hawaii
  • Idaho
  • Indiana
  • Louisiana
  • Massachusetts
  • Maryland
  • Mississippi
  • Missouri
  • Montana
  • Nebraska
  • New Mexico
  • North Carolina
  • North Dakota
  • Ohio
  • South Carolina
  • South Dakota
  • Tennessee
  • Texas
  • Utah
  • Virginia
  • West Virginia
  • Wisconsin

Getting Malpractice Coverage with LeverageRx

Medical malpractice insurance covers the costs associated when a patient accuses a doctor of medical negligence. The insurance policy will pay for settlements awarded to the patient, the cost of arbitration, costs of settling a case before trial, medical damages, punitive and compensatory damages, attorney fees and court costs and fines.

Melissa Brock

Melissa is the owner and founder of College Money Tips. Formerly the editor at Benzinga Money, she has also written for Investopedia, The Balance and Personal Capital. Melissa writes fresh, thought-provoking content (with a touch of humor) about topics in personal finance, higher education, and travel.

READ MORE

Ready to get started?

Compare the best offers for